Betsy DeVos & Co Strike Out in Arizona
In 2006, after vowing in 2005 to veto any and all voucher deals, Governor Janet Napolitano agreed to accept three “school choice” programs as part of a budget compromise:
- Two taxpayer-financed private school voucher programs – one for children with special needs and another for children in foster care (together estimated to cost $5 million per year).
- Increased corporate tax credits for private school tuition (already in effect and capped at $5M, but Napolitano’s compromise raised it to $10M per year).
In return, the Governor received $100M for teacher pay and $160M for full-day kindergarten. These, however, were only temporary gains and have since been cut, while the diversion of public funds to private schools has skyrocketed.
These 2006 voucher bills received their greatest support from Clint Bolick, then the president of the Alliance for School Choice (ACS). ACS was founded in Arizona on May 17, 2004, the 50th anniversary of the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision outlawing segregated schools, Brown v. Board of Education. ACS later launched its C4 arm, the American Federation for Children (AFC), which was chaired and bankrolled by current Secretary of Public Education Betsy DeVos.
Public school advocates warned that these programs would ultimately decimate public schools by diluting already stretched resources and forcing taxpayers to fund separate (and unequal) school systems.
On March 25, 2009, the Arizona Supreme Court unanimously declared Arizona’s school voucher programs unconstitutional. The court based its decision on the ground that vouchers violate an explicit constitutional ban against diverting taxpayer dollars to private and religious schools. Justice Michael Ryan noted that, without changing the Constitution, vouchers could not be implemented in Arizona because “these programs transfer state funds directly from the state treasury to private schools.”
Did the special interests promoting education privatization accept this defeat? Of course not. Watch for the next installment, “Defying the Constitution: Resurrecting Vouchers” which will drop next week.
- Edweek 2006: https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2006/07/12/42ariz.h25.html
- “AZ Vouchers for School Ruled Illegal” (2009) https://tucson.com/news/local/education/precollegiate/az-vouchers-for-schools-ruled-illegal/article_8e7a2285-d989-5943-b347-dc1026af0f58.html